"There's nothing wrong with serving farm-raised shrimp, but what is wrong is when you claim it's local shrimp, which most people are willing to pay a little more for the local shrimp." Mike Eddy of Beacon Fisheries said that to News4JAX in March. The station had just reported the results of a genetic test of shrimp dishes served around Jacksonville.
That test matters most right now. Florida white shrimp are in their October through December peak, according to the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, so the next several weeks are when local shrimp should be easiest to find. The test also shows that the word "Mayport" on a menu often isn't enough to prove it. In Jacksonville Beach, the most dependable source of local shrimp this season is a seafood counter close to the boats. Beachside Seafood, which has anchored Third Street South since 1989, made that same bet this fall.
What 44 Plates Showed
SeaD Consulting ran the study on behalf of the Southern Shrimp Alliance, an industry group for American shrimpers. Researchers collected shrimp dishes from 44 randomly selected restaurants and seafood markets around Jacksonville in March 2026. News4JAX reported these results:
- 14 of 44 dishes, or 32%, were confirmed as authentic American wild-caught shrimp.
- 30 of 44 dishes, or 68%, were imported or farm-raised.
- 25 of 44 establishments, or 57%, described the shrimp as local, Mayport or American wild-caught on the menu or through staff, but testing confirmed the shrimp were imported.
The study also put a price on the mislabeling. Diners paid an average of $2 more per plate for misrepresented shrimp than for authentic American wild-caught shrimp. So a plate labeled local could cost more than one that actually was local. SeaD CEO Erin Williams told the station that Florida has a higher rate of shrimp inauthenticity than other states. She said the North Florida findings would go into a larger eight-state report.
SeaD's own release says its restaurant sampling is not peer-reviewed. It calls the work an initial snapshot rather than a full investigation. The test identified shrimp as American wild-caught or imported. It did not trace any dish to a specific dock, so "authentic" here means American wild-caught, not proven Mayport.
Why Asking Your Server Only Goes So Far
The usual advice is to ask where the shrimp came from. Folio Weekly covered the report in April and pointed out the weakness in that advice. In many cases, customers got confident answers that didn't match the shrimp on the plate.
There isn't much law behind the label, either. The Southern Shrimp Alliance's labeling tracker was updated in September 2026. It lists Florida as having no labeling law and notes that two seafood-labeling bills died in committee in June 2025. Until that changes, the strongest evidence of where shrimp came from is the business's sourcing record, and the March test is one public check on it.
The Jacksonville Beach Addresses That Tested Authentic
Of the 14 establishments confirmed as serving American wild-caught shrimp, three are in Jacksonville Beach. Both News4JAX and Folio Weekly published the names:
- Beachside Seafood, 120 3rd St. S.
- Grouper Shack, 1700 3rd St. S.
- LandShark Bar & Grill, 715 1st St. N.
LandShark is the restaurant at the Margaritaville hotel near the pier. Its current hours run 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and until midnight on Friday and Saturday.
A few minutes north, the list includes Mayport C & C Fisheries Seafood Market at 36 W. 6th St. in Atlantic Beach and Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant at 4378 Ocean St. in Mayport. Three Jacksonville Beach spots on a 14-name list cover a lot of town. One sits on Third Street South near the old downtown, one is further down the same road, and one is a block from the ocean on First Street North.
Beachside Is Turning Toward Its Counter
Beachside is the one name on the list that is changing shape this fall. The restaurant opened in 1989, in a building that dates to 1954, according to First Coast News. Pearl Hospitality Group bought it for $1.57 million in May 2025, Action News Jax reported. Pearl said at the time that it wanted to preserve the longtime staple. Pearl is a Jacksonville company. The Jax Daily Record listed its local businesses as Norikase, Izakaya Ko and Cafecito.
At the end of August, Pearl announced that the upstairs restaurant would wind down in October. Action News Jax reported that the company was moving its focus to the seafood market downstairs, which Pearl called "the heart of this business." General manager Sheila Noffsinger described the plan to First Coast News:
"We are 100 percent keeping the Jax Beach staple, which is our market. We are keeping the market open. We are expanding the market."
The announced renovation adds prepared and grab-and-go items next to the fresh fish. Noffsinger described side dishes customers could take home with their fish and oysters. She said the market "could help prepare an entire dinner for you to take home and cook for your family." Pearl has not settled on the long-term use of the restaurant space.
The March test gives the move some context. Beachside's dish was one of 14 in the Jacksonville area whose shrimp tested as American wild-caught. Under the new plan, the part of the business that keeps running is the counter where shoppers buy seafood to cook at home. Call ahead for the market's current hours and to see how far the renovation has come.
The Counters Within a Short Drive
Safe Harbor's market page says boats unload at the Mayport location. News4JAX named Safe Harbor its JAXBest 2025 seafood winner and reported that the market processes Mayport shrimp for the restaurant and for local stores. Mayport C&C Fisheries opened in 1987 as a wholesale fresh-fish house, according to its own history page, and it now appears in the state's Fresh From Florida retail listing as a local fish market.
| Counter | Address | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Beachside Seafood Market | 120 Third St. S., Jacksonville Beach | Downstairs market, which Pearl says will stay open and expand with prepared sides |
| Mayport C&C Fisheries | 36 W. 6th St., Atlantic Beach | Started as a wholesale fresh-fish house in 1987; its market was on the March list of authentic shrimp |
| Safe Harbor Seafood Market | Ocean Street, Mayport | Boats unload on site; open Tue–Thu 10 a.m.–6 p.m., Fri–Sat 9 a.m.–6 p.m., Sun 10 a.m.–6 p.m., closed Monday |
The timing works in shoppers' favor. FDACS says Florida wild-caught shrimp are available all year, with overall supplies peaking from June through December and white shrimp peaking from October through December. That puts Thanksgiving and the December holidays in the best weeks of the year for buying local shrimp, at the counters where you can see what you're buying before you pay.
For the rest of a Saturday seafood dinner, the Beaches Green Market runs from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Penman Park, 321 Penman Road. From there, Beachside's counter on Third Street South is a short drive.
Here at Willie Lane Group, we keep up with the Beaches at the street level, down to which Third Street counter Pearl decided to keep and which Mayport docks supply the shrimp. If you're thinking about a home within an easy drive of Third Street South or the Mayport docks, Schedule Your Consultation and we'll walk you through the streets around them.